Electric Shadow

Archival #1: MADAM SATAN (1930)

Welcome to a new regular feature dedicated to under-recognized movies that deserve more attention. Whether brought back into print by Manufacture-On-Demand (MOD) services like the Warner Archive Collection or bootstrapped and/or Kickstartered by obsessed entrepreneurial cinephiles, attention must be paid. These are the more obscure, the less-replayed, and those long absent from repertory cinema. Subsequent installments will cover everything from individual movies to TV shows, and multi-movie collections to blessed occasional Blu-rays.

l. to r. Bob (Reginald Denny), wife Angela (Kay Johnson), Bob's pal Jimmy (Roland Young)

l. to r. Bob (Reginald Denny), wife Angela (Kay Johnson), Bob's pal Jimmy (Roland Young)

This (unfortunately) obscure Cecil B. DeMille picture is one of my favorite discoveries from my college days. My "Dance in the Movies" professor showed it to us not just for the electricity-themed, spark-plugs-and-current song and dance number. The real fireworks are the gender politics and (dare I say it?) what we would today call cosplay. Quite notably, the three credited screenwriters are all women, and as much as feminism existed in the early 1930's, this Pre-Code, dark-musical-comedy-disaster movie was as feminist as motion pictures got. Even though the next still frame features a gun, "dark" is relative to the musical comedies of the 1930's.

the best friend, the wife, and the mistress…and a gun

the best friend, the wife, and the mistress…and a gun

Scorned wife Angela (Of Human Bondage's Kay Johnson) turns marital deception around on her philandering husband Bob (Rebecca's Reginald Denny). Demure, sweet, and unassuming otherwise, she eventually takes on a costumed persona who goes by only Madam Satan: an exotic "French" woman full of spice and sin, burning to take a naughty man back to "hell" with her.

miniature work par excelence

miniature work par excelence

By design, her husband finds "Madam Satan" completely irresistible and loses interest in his brassy mistress (Animal Crackers' Lillian Roth). The husband's best friend (Philadelphia Story's Roland Young) gets tangled up in the whole affair doubly, since the climax of the movie occurs at a party he throws on a fancy-schmancy zeppelin. The poster shows parachutes and an exploding zeppelin, so I'll leave it at saying the actors all do their own stunts.

Madam Satan 018.jpg

DeMille is best-known and best-remembered for large-scale epics, and the climactic party on a zeppelin here does not disappoint. Elaborate costumes, a bizarre and decadent tribute to technology in the form of dance, and the bacchanalia of the party itself is an interesting antecedent to the golden calf rave in The Ten Commandments.

I don't care how they accomplish the majority of CG shots in the modern day, but boy am I fascinated by how they pull something like this off.

I don't care how they accomplish the majority of CG shots in the modern day, but boy am I fascinated by how they pull something like this off.

Titular star Kay Johnson had a much shorter career than one would hope (she's magnificent here), but in case you weren't aware, she also happened to be the mother of the great James Cromwell. Lillian Roth underwent the early 1900's version of today's booze-fueled tabloid starlet meltdown, complete with eight marriages. She would eventually become the first celebrity to publicly associate herself with Alcoholics Anonymous, something she deserves as much credit for doing as she does getting herself clean.

Pre-Code movies in general haven't had the best of luck seeing disc or streaming release anywhere other than WB, and especially Warner Archive (who have recently restarted the magnificent Forbidden Hollywood series). There was a VHS, but I don't think Madam Satan ever hit laserdisc, let alone DVD before WAC released it at the end of this past July.

Early talkies have a charm all their own, but this one has more than the average share of surprises and delights. You can buy Madam Satan on DVD for $16.95 by clicking/tapping here or the image below, or try a 2-week free trial of the Warner Archive Instant service and watch it in SD on their site or in HD on a Roku set-top box. Their HD-supporting, AirPlay-enabled iPad app launches soon, too.

Madam Satan from Warner Bros.

Archival is a recurring feature that shines a spotlight on more obscure catalog content, much of which has rarely (if ever) been available to own on home video. 

Return to Soderberghopolis

Criterion is not only returning Soderbergh's King of the Hill to print on home video in February 2014, but they're also including his The Underneath in the same package. I knew it was only a matter of time before we got KOTH, but I'm more grateful to see them having convinced Soderbergh to do an interview about his film that he (allegedly) dislikes the most.

Regarding The Underneath as I wrote about it in the third numbered installment of Soderberghopolis:

"I don’t see the complete clusterfuck he apparently does. I’ve had personal artistic catastrophes others have seen as successes, so I get it. I just don’t agree that it sucks. Imperfect work from a great director is better than what hacks can do on their best days with a papal blessing. I’ll concede that it isn't drenched in Soderbergh's cinematic DNA, but it couldn't have been directed by just anyone. The cinematographic flourishes and this first pass at a non-linear narrative are distinctly Soderbergh."

My "Soderberghopolis" series stalled out once I hit the point I needed to re-watch his two TV series from the early/mid-aughts. Booking time to not just scrub through (as I have with some of the movies) ground it to a halt.

It's finally restarting soon, and I may push that forward even sooner with this tremendously happy news.

I hope this means that not only we'll see the Kafka "Midnight Cut" next year, but maybe a Blu-ray of Schizopolis and at long, long last…The Limey.

I wonder if Extension765 will do a "Perennial Security" t-shirt...

Small Warrior Need Father (#157)

I finally cracked open Paramount's recent restored and remastered Blu-ray of Hondo a couple of nights ago when my wife came across it on the over-the-air MOVIES network. The SD, stretched and distorted picture on the channel was like watching a third-generation VHS copy compared to the rich, bright, crisp colors and details of the Blu-ray.

Hondo 003.jpg

Watching the extras, my wife said "I would pay to go see this in 3D. Why didn't they remaster it in 3D?". I told her, "because, like when this movie came out, 3D is dying again."

THE WORLD'S END Blu-ray Review

Three years ago, I wrote a comprehensive review of the Blu-ray for Edgar Wright's Scott Pilgrim vs the World  Blu-ray roughly 18 hours after it arrived on my doorstep. The Blu-ray of his most recent movie arrived a couple of days ago, and I've finished plowing through every last featurette and commentary. The World's End hits Blu-ray in the US two weeks from today.

As always, screengrabs are taken direct from the disc, then resized to 1000pixel width and compressed from PNG to JPG.

Read More

Skewing Into Massive Popularity

Thanks to my friend Ryan Gallagher for alerting me to this via Twitter. The Ultraviolet consortium, junta, cosa nostra, or whatever have conducted a survey of existing Ultraviolet users.

This has resulted in finding that those surveyed overwhelmingly love the service. This is, of course, as polled from within the very small sample within the portion of the 15% of consumers who even know it exists.

As soon as I'm able to find the time, I'll post a piece about how and why I rip my own Digital Copies from Blu-rays.

The Frame #154: 16mm Friends Forever

Not only did Edgar Wright shoot the flashback sequences featured in The World's End on 16mm celluloid, he shot the whole movie on film.  It makes a difference, and more than just matching well to the other two shot-on-film installments of the Cornetto Trilogy.

My exhaustively comprehensive review of the Blu-ray is almost finished. Three years ago, I did the same for his ultra-stacked Scott Pilgrim vs. the World

The Worlds End 029.jpg

Giant Size #33: Cigar-Smoking Baby

Comics pro Antony Johnston returns to Giant Size and joins Drobo CEO Geoff Barrall to properly school me in the various worlds and characters of the UK's 2000AD , with a particular focus on one-man judge/jury/executioner Judge Dredd. One of my favorite bits of this episode is listening to the two of them enthuse about their childhood discoveries of various stories through 2000AD's ultra-violent (and thoroughly satirical) lens.

This week's interview with colorist extraordinaire Elizabeth Breitweiser begins at the 01:44:52 mark. Pick up Velvet  #1 (written by Ed Brubaker, penciled by Steve Epting, and colored by Elizabeth) and add it to your pull list.

Gaze into the fist of dredd0.jpg

1800+ weekly issues strong, 2000AD has never shied away from political subject matter and the topical since its inception in 1977. What follows is a US-focused reading list of how to get your hands on the biggest, most iconic and interesting stories we discussed in this week's show.

Judge Dredd: The Complete Case Files #02 (progs 61-115)
includes "The Cursed Earth" and "The Day the Law Died" and more
 $15 TPB or $10 Kindle Edition

Dredd goes over land from Mega City One (east coast) to Mega City Two (west coast), with a life-saving vaccine and a convict in tow.  Immediately spilling out of that, one of his biggest early nemeses arises and gives him hell.

Judge Dredd: The Complete Case Files #05 (progs 208-270)
includes "Block Mania" and "The Apocalypse War" and more
 $16 TPB or $10 Kindle Edition 

The most iconic, go-to classic Dredd story sees major, lasting implications for the planet and world of Dredd, replete with Cold War imagery.

The above three collections, for a remarkably reasonable price, collect some of the most definitive early Dredd stories. If you grab #03, you'll get the first appearances of both Judge Death and Judge Anderson, and a bunch of self-contained stories.

The US has only seen six print volumes of the "Complete Case Files" released, whereas they've released 21 of them in the UK. The good news is that they are all available in the 2000AD Newsstand app for iOS. Alternately, you could import the UK editions from Amazon UK.

Judge Dredd: The Complete Case Files #07 (progs 322-375)
"Cry of the Werewolf""The Graveyard Shift""The Haunting of Sector House 9"
£11 TPB

 Antony was very into some of these weirder, horror-tinged stories. How can you resist a story that starts with a cover showing Dredd turning into a werewolf?

Judge Dredd: The Complete Case Files #08 (progs 376-423)
"City of the Damned" 
  £11 TPB or $14 on iOS Newsstand

Time travel finds its way into Dredd stories here, where Dredd and Judge Anderson travel to the future. The story serves as a continuation of "The Judge Child", so make sure you read that one first. For the record, it precedes Chris Claremont's "Days of Future Past" by four years.

2000AD228_Rogue_Trooper.jpg

Unfortunately, many of the other characters we discussed either haven't been reprinted in the US (like Sam Slade Robo-Hunter), or they're out of print (Strontium Dog).

Rogue Trooper: Tales of Nu Earth 1 ($16)
Rogue Trooper: Tales of Nu Earth 2 ($15)

A genetically-engineered soldier on his own against an endless war, the good people at IDW recently announced a new ongoing Rogue Trooper series. These collections are similar in style to the Dredd Complete Case Files.

The Complete Nemesis the Warlock, Volume 1

Put by Kieron Gillen to Matt Fraction as something along the lines of "this is how messed up what we  grew up on is", I'm chomping at the bit to devour Kevin O'Neill art that I've never seen.

Sláine : The Horned God ($18 HC)
Sláine: Warriors Dawn ($14 TPB)
Sláine: Book of Invasions Volume 1 ($16)

Described as a Celtic Conan the Barbarian, he was controversial as an addition to what was considered a sic-fi-only publication. He's proven to stay immensely popular in retrospect. I've no context for the above collections, but they're all that's available in the US. 

The Ballad of Halo Jones ($15 TPB)

A rare female main character, Alan Moore's work here has eluded me thus far, but now I have little excuse. I'm especially ashamed to have not read this, considering how highly acclaimed it is.

 The Complete Alan Moore Future Shocks ($15 TPB)

Including Abelard Snazz and all of Moore's other short stories aside from the bigger scale of both Halo Jones and D.R. and Quinch.

The Complete D.R. and Quinch ($15 TPB) 

Dredd goes across the Cursed Earth and eventually off into space to find a prophesized savior for Mega City One. We spoil a twist about this one during the show. includes , , and  and more  or $14 on iOS Newsstandincludes and more 

Alan Moore's pair of ne'er-do-well college troublemakers is all collected in one neat little trade. 

Harry 20 on the High Rock ( $13)

A wrongly accused man ends up on an orbital prison, and he's forced to survive against the odds. 

 

I'm amazed I got this show recorded and this all written. I'm sick as a dog…a Strontium Dog. 

Screen Time #45: Impact Characters with Grant Bowler

Recorded live at a local Dallas Comic-Con event, I speak with the star of Syfy's Defiance  about being a gamer, making it in acting, and "kicking every chicken in the yard". The first season of is now available on Blu-ray and DVD.

Here are trailers and clips relevant to this week's episode of Screen Time (subscribe in iTunes or via RSS):

American Horror Story: Season 2

The second season just hit Blu-ray and DVD two weeks ago, and the third season is three episodes in and off to a shocking start.

American Horror Story S2 005.jpg

I'm not generally one for full-on horror, but shocking suspense I can handle. The most appealing thing about this series, compared to others I'm digging into late (like I did with Fringe ), is that each season represents about 10 hours of content (over 13 episodes) as opposed to around 17 hours (over 22 episodes) per season. It's much easier to catch up over a lazy weekend.

The only way I can think to describe American Horror Story is that awful, weird, supernatural things happen in this show, and nothing is sacrosanct. The second season has a completely different setting and supporting cast, but it is inextricably linked to the first season. The whole thing is anchored by amazing performances from actors they would have had a hard time getting, were there a longer time commitment for filming, including not only star Jessica Lange, but also her ensemble co-stars James Cromwell, Sarah Paulson, Zachary Quinto, Joseph Fiennes, and others. Season two is set in an asylum where horrible, bizarre things happen and are done.

Fans of the show are rewarded for buying the Blu-ray by the inclusion of some better-than-usual featurettes, but especially by the inclusion of a deleted scenes reel. Picture quality and the DTS-HD Master audio are great, and bitrate is solid, thanks to the choice to go with dual-layer BD-50 discs. Amazon has it for $35, and if you're a Prime member, you can already stream Season 1 for free in HD, or buy the Blu-ray set for the extras at $31.50. Breaking Bad is gone, and you could do worse jumping into this one to add a new ongoing serial to your list of shows you follow.

Apple: 4K for 1K?

Speculation has reached a fever pitch as it often does the day before an Apple product presentation. I've been relatively confident regarding one bit of speculation of my own ever since the WWDC reveal of the new Mac Pro: Apple has a 4K display ready, and the price will be the big surprise.

iPads and refreshed models of Macs and Mavericks, alongside a possible refresh to the iPod line? All of this is widely expected.

The long-awaited halo-end of the Mac line was pitched heavily on the back of its ultra-powered graphics horsepower, and consequently its ability to run up to three 4K monitors at once. The existing Thunderbolt Display also uses three inputs that are made obsolete by the new Mac Pro: Thunderbolt 1, USB 2, and the now ancient -looking FireWire 800.

Only in the last few days have people gotten more confident about predicting a new 4K Thunderbolt Display, and I'm surprised that everyone I've read or heard seem to predict the cost at $3000-$4000.  These people include John Gruber and Marco Arment on the latest installment of The Talk Show, among others.

That price range sounds much more reasonable for the Mac Pro itself. Applied to a desktop display, the hefty price tag runs counter to the trend seen since the introduction of the 24" LED Cinema Display at $899, which replaced a 23" Cinema Display that originally cost $1999. For reference, the 30" Cinema Display from the same line dropped over time from $3300 to $1800.

It would be bizarrely out of character for the flagship Apple display to ratchet up in price at this point. One of the areas where Apple has shored up its component purchasing leverage in particular is in displays, including both iMacs on the large end and phones and tablets at the smaller end.

Aisin Seiki has been selling a $700 39" 4KTV (and a $1000 50" model) since April. I'm not saying that directly correlates to Apple's ability to price a 4K "Retina" display at the $999 point of the Thunderbolt Display, but if anyone in the computing industry has the component volume leverage to be first to move, it's Apple. If Apple can, they will, and it would be a hell of a precursor to a late 2014 TV set launch.

I wouldn't necessarily peg the same 27" size as the Thunderbolt for what I'm calling the Retina Pro Display, but it would make the most logical sense for it to be offered in the size of their largest iMac. That way, it would begin to drive down component pricing  so that the iMac line could go 4K next year and not have an impact on margins. Refreshed MacBook Pros and even Mac mini models would have to support the new display resolution with beefed up graphics cards, but perhaps the theoretical new Air models wouldn't...or perhaps only at a reduced resolution.

It's not really Apple's style anymore to wow people with how much more than the old product their new thing costs.  Whether it's Phil Schiller or Tim Cook who drops the news, an Apple 4K Display for $999 that works with their hot new Mac Pro would be a great way to sell multiples of three of them.

You know who really wins if this turns out? Whichever monitor arm mount manufacturer makes a three-headed model. 

Post Script (11:30am CT 22 October 2013)

In 2012, Aisin Seiki (which generally does business as "Seiki" in the US) licensed Vizio's QAM patent portfolio.  Those who dismiss them as a second-rate "Asian third party" are ignoring the fact that they are using the same core signal processing technology as one of the biggest LCD TV manufacturers in the United States. What I can't personally speak to is the signal processing and upconversion quality of their Ultra HD offerings. Could part of Apple's "fab-less" chip design strategy, with regard to graphics in particular, be geared toward reducing their overhead in display chipsets?

2nd Post Script (1:30pm CT 22 October 2013) 

So my 4K/Retina desktop display prediction didn't pan out...yet. I stand by the pricing and positioning logic above, and expect some sort of movement during the coming months.

Leave Calvin and Hobbes (and Bill Watterson) Alone

I've never bought an issue of Mental Floss, but boy am I going to when their December issue containing an interview with Bill Watterson is on stands

Calvin and Hobbes is one of my absolute favorite works of sequential art. I love seeing comics adapted for the screen, both in animation and live action. I completely agree with Watterson regarding Calvin and Hobbes  staying in its original medium and not succumbing to adaptation:

Years ago, you hadn’t quite dismissed the notion of animating the strip. Are you a fan of Pixar? Does their competency ever make the idea of animating your creations more palatable?
The visual sophistication of Pixar blows me away, but I have zero interest in animating Calvin and Hobbes. If you’ve ever compared a film to a novel it’s based on, you know the novel gets bludgeoned. It’s inevitable, because different media have different strengths and needs, and when you make a movie, the movie’s needs get served. As a comic strip, Calvin and Hobbes works exactly the way I intended it to. There’s no upside for me in adapting it.

I think there could be a good way to translate C&H  to animation, but not as a franchise series of features or a TV show. If anything, animated shorts need to become something people can digest in ways other than Disney or Fox or WB (or whomever) slapping them in front of occasional mega-budget movies. It could  be done well, but if Watterson isn't involved, it's just the same as The All-New, All-Different, Ted-Geisel-Free Lorax to me: wolves in sheep's clothing.

Kumar Pallana

Kumar Pallana has always been one of my favorite parts of my very favorite Wes Anderson movies. He lived a long life, to the age 94. I would defy anyone to prove that he is not just as important to the success of Bottle Rocket as superstars-to-be Owen and Luke Wilson. I've really missed seeing him in post-Darjeeling movies from Anderson.

Kumar also founded Dallas' Cosmic Cafe, a much-beloved haunt. 

I took some fresh grabs from his performances in his four turns with American Empirical Pictures. Enjoy.

Kumar Bottle Rocket 010.jpg
Kumar Bottle Rocket 019.jpg
Kumar Rushmore 020.jpg
Kumar Royal Tenenbaums 016.jpg
Kumar Royal Tenenbaums 028.jpg
Kumar Royal Tenenbaums 029.jpg
Kumar Royal Tenenbaums 040.jpg
Kumar Darjeeling Limited 009.jpg
Kumar Bottle Rocket 001.jpg

Esper-ation

Square Enix just dropped Final Fantasy V on iOS and Android, recently announced Final Fantasy IV: The After Years (a sequel with an awful literal title released to phones in Japan) for this winter, and have now told Kotaku that Final Fantasy VI is on the way too.

You would think the big sales success of these would result in porting of many more Role-Playing Games of yesteryear, but they Japanese studios are playing the Disney Vault approach with these as ever.  RPGs work on touch (even better with tilt support), whereas platformers are a mess.

I'm so big a fan especially of FFIV that I considered buying a PSVita at one point just so I could finally play the sequel.  FFVI is right neck-and-neck with IV as my favorite in the series. I've wanted them legitimately on my phone for ages. If only there were an "original graphics mode"...

Blu-grade: LOVE ACTUALLY 10th Anniversary Edition

I know, more than any other catalog re-release, everyone was clamoring to know whether the four-year-old Blu-ray of Love Actually has been made obsolete by next week's "All-New 10th Anniversary Digital Restoration" Edition.

"Digital Restoration", my eye.

UPDATE (11 Oct 2013): It's come to my attention that aside from an AVC encode rather than VC-1, the notable difference is that this new disc is the US soundtrack cut rather than UK, so it features a track by Kelly Clarkson during the office party sequence instead of one by Sugababes, just as US audiences originally heard regardless.

There is no difference in supplemental features compared to the 2009 disc. The new one adds a DVD, iTunesHD/Ultraviolet code, and a really cheap tin ornament.

Looking at the core feature file on each Blu-ray reveals that they are different sizes (about 2GB different). I'll be damned if I can tell a difference by looking at them. Color, texture detail, and other things like black levels and overall contrast look effectively identical to me. I did not re-watch the original disc the whole way through nor the new one, but watched the opening 20 minutes of each, along with a few minutes-long sequences throughout (specifically the "All I Want For Christmas is You" bit). Maybe they re-encoded a tiny bit and re-did the BD-Live ads or something, but in ways someone who loves or likes the movie would notice, the discs are functionally identical. Oh, I did find one difference...the menu loop video fills more of the screen now.

The below gallery denotes from which release each image was captured, merely resized to fit the site width. they are not frame-to-frame matches, but representative of roughly the same moments in particular scenes.

In case you were wondering...as cloying and didactic and obvious and stupid as this movie is, I like it a hell of a lot, in spite of myself and my generally gourmand taste profile.

Bottom Line

The new one is pre-orderable for $19, but the basically-the-exact-same one is a better buy for $5 cheaper at $14.  The ornament, Digital Copy (no iTunes Extras), and a DVD aren't worth $5 more to me, but therein lie the difference. It doesn't seem like they are taking the 2009 disc out of print, but they might. alternately, it could be in the $7.99 bin at you big box retailer this winter.

Come Out and (Don't) Watch THE LITTLE MERMAID In Theatres!

The Little Mermaid is the first movie I saw in a theater. The theater had a coloring contest upon exit, and I won a copy of the one-sheet that hangs in my parents' house to this day. I love the movie and sing songs from it at karaoke. I would pay to see it in a theater again, just as I would many other Disney Animated Classics.

I loathe the idea that there will be any children whose first cinematic experience will be sitting in a theater in front of an iPad instead of being enveloped in the experience. Their instructions:

Bring your iPad with you to the movie
Interact with the film, play games, sing along, find new surprises and compete with the audience
Download the free app before you arrive at the theatre
Requires Second Screen Live app and iPad or iPad mini with iOS 5.0 or higher

Thankfully, it looks like only 12 theaters nationwide are doing this crap: six in California, one in Manhattan, two in suburban NYC, and one each in New Jersey, Kansas, and Texas (Plano).

Here's an idea, Disney: do limited re-releases of your animated classics in theaters once a quarter like you did when I was a kid and create new fans instead of behaviorally-trained distraction drones.

UltraViolet vs. iTunes Digital Copy: Studio Breakdown

I'm often asked whether "[Studio]/[Movie]" still does iTunes Digital Copy or not anymore. Some answers are cut and dry, and others are not. I will update/addend this piece over time.

ONLY UltraViolet

  • Sony
  • Warner Bros./DC
  • Fox Searchlight (as of Summer 2013)
  • NBC/Universal/USA/Syfy TV

Depending on the title, the UV code may or may not redeem for HD.

BOTH iTunes + Ultraviolet

  • 20th Century Fox & Fox Animation
  • Universal (movies only)
  • Paramount (new release only)
  • Lionsgate/Summit

Recent releases have seen the iTunes codes redeem for the HD versions of movies (Paramount sequels seem to deliver as double features of late). UltraViolet codes redeem for SD only unless otherwise marked.

Digital Copy Plus (Choose One: Vudu/Amazon/iTunes)

  • Disney/Pixar/Touchstone/Marvel

You get to choose from the services it offers you when you redeem the code. Sometimes it's all three (Oz the Great and Powerful), but I've found that sometimes, you don't get iTunes as an option (The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh ). Note that Vudu equals UltraViolet.

iTunes includes Extras

  • Pixar
  • Disney Classics Diamond Editions (starting with The Little Mermaid) 
  • Paramount (new release only)
  • Lionsgate/Summit
  • some pre-Fall 2013 Universal (new release only)

All of the above is why I make my own digital copies from Blu-rays when there's no iTunes code. 

UPDATE 4 November 2013: Added above, a breakdown of iTunes Digital Copy studios that include iTunes Extras.

Exclusive Best Buy INTO DARKNESS Extras...Not on a Disc?

Last week, I covered the majority of what I found interesting and/or troubling about the situation with retailer exclusives relative to the Star Trek Into Darkness Blu-ray.

Now, the day before release, I'm wondering why the Target set ($27.99) costs more than the Best Buy one ($19.99), since they both advertise the same amount of extra content (30 minutes). The Target one has another disc, as depicted all over. In this week's Best Buy newspaper ad, it denotes the following about the $8 cheaper BB-exclusive, which I previously gave some relative praise:

30 minutes of exclusive content delivered via CinemaNow

So the exclusive content is only available on yet another proprietary streaming service?