Gypsy, In the Heights, The Little Mermaid, South Pacific and Young Frankenstein: The Musical

I can vouch for the bolded choices, and I've listened to all five. Read between the bold. I've been a bad Broadway enthusiast this year, so I should have five or six things that have better albums than Mermaid. I'll work on including that in the will-never-be-finished piece I've been working on

By the numbers:

2 revivals
2 movie adaptations
1 Disney
1 Mel Brooks
1 Patti Lupone show
1 completely original show
17 is how many times iTunes says I've listened to the South Pacific album, the only recording of it I've listened to more than once or all the way through